+- Too Many Message Boards (http://tmmb.mywire.org)
+-- Forum: General Topics (http://tmmb.mywire.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Opinion and Politics (http://tmmb.mywire.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=75)
+--- Thread: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner (/showthread.php?tid=1145)
Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - ObeWan - 20-02-2022
Did anyone else catch it?
What were your impressions of the Police Commissioner and the answers he provided?
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Oh_hunnihunni - 20-02-2022
I did, and I think his humanity is admirable.
But I doubt it will solve the problem.
I did yell 'water cannon' at the tv when he spoke about tear gas and batons... but really, I am very glad I am not in his shoes....
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Magoo - 20-02-2022
i dont know how it is in the public service, but in business sometimes difficult decisions have to be made.
Decisions that might self destruct a job.
but why would you sell out the public to appease a small minority. why have you compromised your institution and public safety for 'i think' and 'i feel'.
not your job buckwheat, enforce the laws as you are mandated by legislation and your oath to that institution.
Answer to that. if it all turned to custard he could at least retain the respect as man who stood behind his convictions and the job he has by oath promised to do. Not someone who took upon himself to escalate this into what it has become.
they should have let me interview him.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - ObeWan - 20-02-2022
For me there were a number of his answers that made me raise an eyebrow.
But the one telling question from Tame was:
Tame: ÔÇ£How do you think this will play out in the end?ÔÇØ (or similar).
Coster: ÔÇ£I donÔÇÖt knowÔÇØ
Tame: ÔÇ£ You donÔÇÖt know?ÔÇØ
This guy is truly naive.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Oh_hunnihunni - 20-02-2022
In a world where targets and outcomes are vitally important that answer raised my eyebrows too.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Magoo - 20-02-2022
this guy has proven that we dont really need a police force,
if this is the standard to which they are held.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Olive - 20-02-2022
I've read today that Coster has been let down by his threat assessment staff, who are part of the faction in NZ Police who resent him and his modern philosophy of policing by consent. That explains why he didn't give instructions to take down the occupation while it was still manageable - they assessed the threat as low.
The thing that baffles me is that there seems to have been no effort to establish a perimeter and prevent new occupiers from coming in.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - ObeWan - 20-02-2022
(20-02-2022, 11:08 AM)Olive Wrote: I've read today that Coster has been let down by his threat assessment staff, who are part of the faction in NZ Police who resent him and his modern philosophy of policing by consent.  That explains why he didn't give instructions to take down the occupation while it was still manageable - they assessed the threat as low.Indeed baffling.
The thing that baffles me is that there seems to have been no effort to establish a perimeter and prevent new occupiers from coming in.
The questioning from Tame went something along the lines of:
Tame: Do you have powers to establish roadblocks and search vehicles?
Coster: We are not doing that at the moment.
Tame: Can you establish a perimeter to prevent more vehicles joining?
Coster: That is not something we are considering.
Tame: Do the Police have power to stop anyone taking a tent onto Parliament grounds?
Coster: Yes, but we are not doing that.
Tame: So I could take a pergola or sleeping bag onto Parliament grounds and nobody would stop me?
Coster: Yes.
And after the interview ended Tame noted that Coster had clarified that Police had powers to set up roadblocks but it was not something currently being used.
And this is our top cop! God save us!
Commentators call him ÔÇ£Cuddles CosterÔÇØ. Simon Bridges publicly accused him of being a ÔÇ£wokesterÔÇØ. And frontline officers have nicknamed him The Lantern (very bright but needs carrying).
So just who is the man in charge of New ZealandÔÇÖs police? And why is he taking a softly, softly approach to the rabble of protesters camping on ParliamentÔÇÖs lawn and paralysing downtown Wellington?
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/127801879/nzs-top-cop-who-is-andrew-coster-the-man-struggling-to-deal-with-the-parliament-protests
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Oh_hunnihunni - 20-02-2022
I wonder if I took a sleeping bag onto the grounds of Government House the Police might object?
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Lilith7 - 20-02-2022
I tend to agree with him - nobody wants this to end violently, & if that means putting up with these alleged protesters then so be it.
If it was up to me, I might arrange food sup[lies for them, laced with sleeping pills & have them peacefully removed in the wee small hours
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Praktica - 20-02-2022
(20-02-2022, 12:31 PM)Lilith7 Wrote: I tend to agree with him - nobody wants this to end violently, & if that means putting up with these alleged protesters then so be it.Better still - use laxatives, and turn the whole thing into a shitshow.
If it was up to me, I might arrange food sup[lies for them, laced with sleeping pills & have them peacefully removed in the wee small hours
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Lilith7 - 20-02-2022
(20-02-2022, 01:23 PM)Praktica Wrote:You know, on balance - I definitely prefer your idea!(20-02-2022, 12:31 PM)Lilith7 Wrote: I tend to agree with him - nobody wants this to end violently, & if that means putting up with these alleged protesters then so be it.Better still - use laxatives, and turn the whole thing into a shitshow.
If it was up to me, I might arrange food sup[lies for them, laced with sleeping pills & have them peacefully removed in the wee small hours
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Wainuiguy - 02-03-2022
(20-02-2022, 08:23 AM)ObeWan Wrote: Did anyone else catch it?Coster comes across as a soft cock of the highest degree.  Soft on the protesters, soft on gangs.  Road policing and drink driving enforcement is at all time lows.  Police morale is at all time lows.
What were your impressions of the Police Commissioner and the answers he provided?
My boss, ex Police, considers him to be one of the worst Commissioners to wear the uniform.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Magoo - 02-03-2022
(02-03-2022, 11:00 AM)Wainuiguy Wrote:agreed(20-02-2022, 08:23 AM)ObeWan Wrote: Did anyone else catch it?Coster comes across as a soft cock of the highest degree.  Soft on the protesters, soft on gangs.  Road policing and drink driving enforcement is at all time lows.  Police morale is at all time lows.
What were your impressions of the Police Commissioner and the answers he provided?
My boss, ex Police, considers him to be one of the worst Commissioners to wear the uniform.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - C_T_Russell - 03-03-2022
I thought the police did a good job at the beginning, but they got pretty violent at the end, I think it could have been handled a bit better than how they did.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - harm_less - 03-03-2022
(03-03-2022, 02:00 PM)C_T_Russell Wrote: I thought the police did a good job at the beginning, but they got pretty violent at the end, I think it could have been handled a bit better than how they did.When they're being pelted with all manner of debris from cobble stones to tent poles and the wellbeing of the kids within the protestors camp is under thread due to arsonists I fully agree with the Police turning up their level of action in reply.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Lilith7 - 03-03-2022
(03-03-2022, 02:04 PM)harm_less Wrote:I don't think they had much choice, once things started going pear shaped.(03-03-2022, 02:00 PM)C_T_Russell Wrote: I thought the police did a good job at the beginning, but they got pretty violent at the end, I think it could have been handled a bit better than how they did.When they're being pelted with all manner of debris from cobble stones to tent poles and the wellbeing of the kids within the protestors camp is under thread due to arsonists I fully agree with the Police turning up their level of action in reply.
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - Magoo - 03-03-2022
(03-03-2022, 02:00 PM)C_T_Russell Wrote: I thought the police did a good job at the beginning, but they got pretty violent at the end, I think it could have been handled a bit better than how they did.the police were very patient to begin. everyone was.
when it was realised that they werent legitimate protesters, just disaffected idiots with chips on shoulders that patience dried up.
it all could have been avoided if those criminals had gone home. the police did an excellent job.
they could have used a baton charge and tear gas but thats life i spose
RE: Q+A Interview with Police Commissioner - ObeWan - 03-03-2022
I actually think they showed amazing restraint given the provocation.
FYI an elderly gent who was not part of the protest was hit in the head and injured by a paving stone thrown by one of your ÔÇ£peaceful, loving peopleÔÇØ. He was assisted by a Police office who arranged paramedic attention.
Bit over the top by Police eh?